Morristown Pizzeria Ranked The Best In NJ, DoorDash Says

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned Pizza on South Street just scored the top spot in New Jersey on DoorDash’s “Battle of the Slices 2026” list, making it the Garden State’s only entry among 40 pizzerias recognized nationwide. The shop is run by Nino Coniglio, an 11-time World Pizza Championship winner who also took home a win on Food Network’s “Chopped,” so the pedigree behind those pies is no joke.